Question dossierOrdivon Hosttesting

Can Host complete a general repository Goal without absorbing Runtime mechanics?

Test semantic continuity on real engineering work while preserving the Host–Runtime boundary.

01 / Current position

A hypothesis is not the current judgment.

The dossier preserves the live research position. Dated articles preserve the complete evidence and argument that changed it.

Working hypothesis

Host can own Goal, Task, candidate admission, Harness assignment, verification, and Outcome while Runtime exclusively owns Workspaces, Jobs, process trees, and physical evidence.

Current judgment

Strongly supported but still bounded. H2–H6 established continuation; Harness H1–H5 completed a frozen repository-repair workload in both Codex/Hermes replacement orders, rejected stale and missing-Artifact completion claims, recovered a dropped repair response without redispatch, and committed TaskOutcome only after independent Runtime acceptance. A broader unbounded repository Goal remains outstanding.

02 / Decision boundary

What keeps this Question alive?

Why it matters

Host only matters if semantic continuity survives real work; a demo loop that cannot cross restart, model replacement, and ambiguous effects does not establish a state owner.

Next admitted test

Run one broader multi-step repository Goal with open-ended decomposition across Host restart and later Harness replacement while preserving admitted decisions, unknown-effect handling, and acceptance evidence.

Condition for deletion

If Host must copy process, Workspace, or Artifact truth to continue correctly—or loses semantic commitments when those objects remain in Runtime—the boundary is wrong.

03 / Supporting publications

Complete arguments connected to this Question.

2 dated publications currently document this research line.

04 / Source discipline

The dossier is an index, not the evidence authority.

Question metadata

Owns the current judgment, next test, and deletion condition.

Publications

Own complete dated arguments, limitations, comparisons, and source links.

Repositories

Own exact code, tests, releases, receipts, and machine evidence.