Question dossierOrdivon Hostreframed

What semantic work should Host preserve when broader work continues across sessions?

Retain durable Task identity and the bounded semantic frontier without turning Host into a Goal coordinator, executor, Runtime proxy, or domain-completion authority.

01 / Current position

A hypothesis is not the current judgment.

The dossier preserves the live research position. Dated articles preserve the complete evidence and argument that changed it.

Working hypothesis

Host only needs Task identity/revision, Journal/CAS admission, WorkingCheckpoint continuity, bounded handoff/inspection, and opaque owner references; broader Goal coordination and external execution can remain consumer-local.

Current judgment

Reframed by the 0.3 contraction. The original ‘broader Goal completion’ target was too broad: Host deliberately removed shared Goal coordination, caller-neutral foreign execution, Runtime integration residue, generic capability policy, and legacy execution workloads. Current 0.4.x preserves the semantic work claim and revalidation hints while cognition, execution, source currentness, external occurrence, and domain completion remain owner-native.

02 / Decision boundary

What keeps this Question alive?

Why it matters

A continuity component can preserve useful work while still becoming harmful if it silently absorbs planning, execution, currentness, or domain truth merely because those facts are convenient to resume from.

Next admitted test

Treat the narrowed 0.4.x continuity journey as the standing answer. Reopen shared coordination only if a named cross-session workload repeatedly loses a Host-owned semantic fact that WorkingCheckpoint plus direct owner revalidation cannot preserve.

Condition for deletion

A real workload repeatedly requires Host itself to own a stable coordination or completion fact—not merely reference it—and direct consumer/owner composition cannot recover correctly with less shared machinery.

03 / Supporting publications

Complete arguments connected to this Question.

2 dated publications currently document this research line.

04 / Source discipline

The dossier is an index, not the evidence authority.

Question metadata

Owns the current judgment, next test, and deletion condition.

Publications

Own complete dated arguments, limitations, comparisons, and source links.

Repositories

Own exact code, tests, releases, receipts, and machine evidence.