Question dossierOrdivon Computinganswered

Which Agent-native responsibilities remain after strong classical baselines?

Use mature workflow, retrieval, idempotency, and provider systems to delete any shared abstraction that does not own a distinct failure.

01 / Current position

A hypothesis is not the current judgment.

The dossier preserves the live research position. Dated articles preserve the complete evidence and argument that changed it.

Working hypothesis

Task meaning belongs in Host, physical execution truth in Runtime, and correlated external interaction may belong in World; durable workflow mechanics, generalized Context state, and provider-specific lifecycle can remain in mature systems or owning applications.

Current judgment

Answered within the Round 1 boundary. LangGraph and Temporal carried durable work state; current-revision retrieval matched the tested Context need; single-backend Effect machinery shrank to identity, UNKNOWN, correlation, reconciliation, and no blind redispatch; live provider replacement preserved Task state without proving model equivalence.

02 / Decision boundary

What keeps this Question alive?

Why it matters

A proposed core becomes permanent inheritance. It should contain only responsibilities that survive strong alternatives, multiple workloads, cost measurement, and a deletion test.

Next admitted test

Use the result as an admission test in World W1 and Harness H4–H5. Reopen the shared-core boundary only when a materially different workload exposes an unowned non-bypassable responsibility.

Condition for deletion

A future workload repeatedly fails because a stable responsibility cannot remain in Host, Runtime, World, a mature workflow engine, or a provider-faithful adapter.

03 / Supporting publications

Complete arguments connected to this Question.

3 dated publications currently document this research line.

04 / Source discipline

The dossier is an index, not the evidence authority.

Question metadata

Owns the current judgment, next test, and deletion condition.

Publications

Own complete dated arguments, limitations, comparisons, and source links.

Repositories

Own exact code, tests, releases, receipts, and machine evidence.